Dating with muhammad

Rated 4.38/5 based on 573 customer reviews

Some academics now say that the impact of the text could be comparable to finding a copy of the Gospels dating back to before the time of Christ.Historian Tom Holland told the that evidence was now mounting that traditional accounts of Islam’s origins are wrong.“It destabilises, to put it mildly, the idea that we can know anything with certainty about how the Koran emerged — and that in turn has implications for the historicity of Muhammad and the Companions [his followers],” he said.Other very old Korans also seem to confirm that written texts were circulating before Mohammed’s death.Needless to say, Muslim academics have disputed the claims.

dating with muhammad-52

dating with muhammad-31

dating with muhammad-52

The carbon dating, which is considered to be extremely accurate, suggests that the Quran may have actually been written before Muhammad was alive, or during the early years of his childhood.” These results may cause controversy among scholars as Islam’s Prophet Mohammad—believed to be the historic founder of Islam and “messenger of god” to Muslims— was thought to have been born in 570 AD and to have died in 632 AD.“The final authoritative written form was not completed until 650AD under the third leader Caliph Uthman”.The Quran is the most sacred book of the Islamic faith, and Muslims consider it the direct word of god.Scientists at the University of Oxford had already revealed that the parchment was among the oldest known Koranic texts in the world, but now several historians say it could be so old that it pre-dates the Muslim prophet, thus contradicting traditional accounts of his life and radically altering “the edifice of Islamic tradition.” The dating reveals the text to have been written between AD568 and 645, while the dates of Mohammed’s life are traditionally given as AD570 to 632.This means that at the very latest it was written before the first formal texts were supposed to have been collated, and at the earliest it was written before or shortly after Mohammed was born.

Leave a Reply